Michigan’s New House Bill 6233 Wants To Ban EV Automakers From Doing Business

Cars

Published on September 20th, 2020 |
by Johnna Crider

September 20th, 2020 by  


Michigan politicians are trying to block new electric vehicle manufacturers from doing business in the state. Although carefully worded to include any type of auto manufacturing company, the Michigan “Motor Vehicle Franchise Act” was created specifically to block Tesla from doing business there, an obvious favor to the dealerships. The law already includes certain restrictions on auto manufacturers, restrictions that limit their ability to sell and service their vehicles in the state.

The upside to this bill is that the language leaves room for creative solutions — such as the 2016 settlement brought by Tesla against the state. The Michigan Attorney General interpreted existing law to allow Tesla and other manufacturers certain sales-type activities at gallery locations. These include consumer education about products (such as EVs), discussions about the price, offering test drives, and discussing financing in order to facilitate online orders and delivery. The only restriction was that the transfer of the title of the vehicle had to take place out of state, to comply with existing law.

A new house bill in Michigan, however, has been introduced by Representative Sheppard to amend the law so that no manufacturer except Tesla can support the sales or service of their vehicles in Michigan. Although Tesla stands to gain from this, it would go against its core mission and I believe it would actually harm Tesla. The company already gets a lot of criticism and outright hate from some of its ardent critics.

The gist of the new bill, House Bill 6233, is that any new auto manufacturer — a company that does not already have an establishment in Michigan — can not come in, set one up, and do business. This is a bold attempt to block the sales of electric vehicles from new companies — whether they be Rivian, Lucid Motors, Xpeng, or another startup — to residents in Michigan. You can read the full bill here.

It Seems Like Tesla Benefits, But It Really Doesn’t

Many Tesla supporters believe in Tesla’s mission, which is to accelerate the world’s transition to sustainable energy. In this regard, the more EV automakers there are, the merrier. We need more EVs on the road. They save lives. A recent study by the American Lung Association showed that if auto sales switch fully to EVs by 2045, this could save at least 6,300 American lives — and prevent 93,000 asthma attacks — a year. Even Tesla’s CEO, Elon Musk, values other EV makers making a serious and compelling attempt — who he does not see as actual competition for Tesla.

What Can Be Done To Help?

I spoke with James Chen, Rivian’s Vice President of Public Policy, and he shared his thoughts with me about how frustrating this is. The push for this bill is being spearheaded by conventional dealerships that are threatened by electric vehicles.

“This is the franchised dealers trying to stifle legit competition and prevent the advancement of zero-emissions vehicle technology,” Chen told me. Rivian, an independent U.S. manufacturer of all-electric trucks and SUVs would be blocked from doing business in Michigan if this bill is accepted into law.

The crazy thing is that, here we have an independent private manufacturer — an American company even — being blocked from participating in the “free market” by a state. Chen explained that the incumbent business interests — the dealers — are trying to use legislation to block out all new transportation technologies. “If the franchise dealer model is so great,” he asked me on the phone, “why are they afraid of legitimate competition?”

Chen also elaborated on the focus of the legislation. Legislation should be focused on the worldwide pandemic and challenging budget issues, yet the dealers are rushing this bill through. Why? “Why are the dealers pushing a bill to stifle economic investment into the state by EV manufacturers?”

Rivian R1S

These are very good questions, and the answer is: follow the money. It all comes back to money — dealers have lost money with Tesla’s business model, “buying directly from the manufacturer and bypassing the dealer altogether,” and this is their way of trying to fight back. The dealers will fight — simply because the elimination of the middle man would be bad for them.

As for what can be done to help fight this from outside — awareness. It’s pretty much all we can do. Letting the voters know what they are voting for and educating them about the shady backroom dealings that take place between vested interests and the politicians involved.

Bonnie Norman, whose role as an early EV adopter (owner of an original Tesla Roadster and also an early investor) wanted to lend support to the other EV manufacturers who are doing their part. “While I’m not surprised to see Michigan playing protectionist games again, it’s really heartwarming to see so many Tesla owners jumping in to help shed light on what is going on in the Michigan legislature. The mission is about accelerating the transition to sustainable energy. In the past, EV owners of all brands have shown up to help Tesla in various state battles. We will be there for Rivian, Bollinger, Lucid, and others as they fight to sell an American product in the US.

“The mission is about accelerating the transition to sustainable energy. In the past, EV owners of all brands have shown up to help Tesla in various state battles. We will be there for Rivian, Bollinger, Lucid, and others as they fight to sell American-made products in the US.”

 
 


 


Appreciate CleanTechnica’s originality? Consider becoming a CleanTechnica member, supporter, or ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.

Sign up for our free daily newsletter or weekly newsletter to never miss a story.

Have a tip for CleanTechnica, want to advertise, or want to suggest a guest for our CleanTech Talk podcast? Contact us here.


Latest Cleantech Talk Episode


Tags: , , , , ,


About the Author

is a Baton Rouge artist, gem, and mineral collector, member of the International Gem Society, and a Tesla shareholder who believes in Elon Musk and Tesla. Elon Musk advised her in 2018 to “Believe in Good.”

Tesla is one of many good things to believe in. You can find Johnna on Twitter